Do you wish you could return to a moment in your past?

 


You could interpret this question however you want -- does it imply that you would be changing some chosen event from your past, or that you would simply stand by and spectate it? Or is it implying that you’d be able to turn back time, taking yourself to that exact moment, being the same you with your current knowledge and life experience, simply transported into the body of your past self?

Let’s take a look through each interpretation. If I were only able to return to a moment in my past to spectate, much like watching a sports game on the sidelines, I don’t think I would particularly wish to do so. The moment I, or most people would return to would probably be something of meaning or impact. Generalizing these two categories, the moments would probably be sorted into (1) returning to the past to see something I enjoyed or (2) returning to a point of regret to see what I could’ve done differently. Even though option 1 might seem like a good idea at first, because I’d be returning to a moment of happiness, I fear that once I’m done spectating that moment, I’ll only feel more unhappy with my current reality. In case 2 mentioned above, the regret from that moment I feel may only get worse if I realize there could’ve been a way to avoid a problem in the past.

Some say it might be cliché to say “don’t dwell on the past” and “what’s done is done”, but it’s wise advice. I believe that if there aren't any changes that can be made, the past is better left alone as time is best spent moving forward, and not looking back. Life is best lived looking towards the future, and not over analyzing the past. 

Now looking at the other interpretation, speculating that I can not only travel to my past, but actively participate in changing it. I could go both ways with this, depending on the circumstances surrounding me. If I were returning to my past self in full form, meaning memories, experiences, and characteristics of myself would revert to those of that moment, I would not want to return to the past. As people often do, I look at my past self and see naivety. As much as there is bliss in ignorance and I could argue that I was so much happier “back then”, I think the experiences I went through are important to remember. After all, we usually don’t know we did something wrong or ill-advised until we experience the repercussions of our actions. And who’s to say that, without all the knowledge I’ve gained through past experiences, I wouldn’t go on to make the exact same mistakes that I would’ve otherwise?

Sure I could turn back time regardless, but what would I gain? I think in this situation, the more important question to ask is: what would I lose? Through the hits we take through life, above everything, we learn. We learn from our mistakes, and this is the knowledge, no matter how painful a certain experience I had to go through was to gain it, I would never give up. 

If I were able to keep my memories as well as change my past however, I think I would indeed wish to return to a moment in my past. Regrets of the past are such a common burden many of us, including me, share. Given the chance within these specific conditions, I would definitely want to redo many situations differently to avoid a number of troubles I went through. Even though I might be led into other difficulties, I would be equipped with the experience and knowledge of my future self to navigate through them better. 


Comments

  1. I really like how you approached this prompt by analyzing the different things it could imply and your different responses depending on which interpretation you chose. Figuring out what the question was asking exactly was something that I also struggled with for this prompt, so I thought your analysis was very clever. I also liked the conversational tone that you use here, it makes the essay much more engaging to read. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I enjoyed seeing you explore all the different interpretations of the prompt, and you used a good conversational tone throughout. I especially enjoyed the first two of the last three paragraphs where you explored the experiences you could lose and the relative naïveté of you past self. I would, however, suggest expanding the last paragraph. There is a lot of relatability in "Regrets of the past are such a common burden many of us, including me, share," but I think it could be even better if you gave specific examples of what you would go back and change (if you were comfortable with that, of course).

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you do a great job of analyzing what the prompt is really asking. I like how you explain different interpretations of the same question. The third paragraph about cliché sayings was helpful to provide new perspective. Overall, really good essay!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your tone isn't super casual for a personal essay, but if that's your usual writing tone I think it's probably alright. I really like the thought behind your answers and how you analyze the prompt, but I think it may be more reflective of who you are as a person (what you have already reflects some of your values and how you think, so it's already good!) if you focus on one situation where you would go to the past. That way, I think you have more opportunity to develop your character and show the reader who you are and what made you. Of course, this is only my opinion and to be honest I don't really know what I'm doing.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I used the same prompt for my essay, and there were a lot of different directions I considered taking with it, so it's interesting to see how you explained your different interpretations. I thought your informal, conversational tone was pretty close to what Lopate described in the reading. One thing you might want to add is an example of a memory you regret/would want to return to. Other than that, good job!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How often do you leave your comfort zone?

Is “doing nothing” a good use of your time?